‹ Back

Understanding Runbooks, Policies, and Procedures in IT Service Management

---

Introduction

In Managed Services Provider (MSP) environments, documentation plays a critical role in ensuring reliable, consistent, and compliant service delivery. Yet, many organizations often blur the distinctions between different types of documents, such as runbooks, policies, and procedures. Each serves a unique purpose: runbooks operationalize routine tasks, policies establish governance frameworks, and procedures (or Standard Operating Procedures, SOPs) provide step-by-step guidance for standardized execution. Understanding their similarities, differences, and contributions is essential for aligning service management practices with business outcomes. This paper explores these document types, introduces guidelines as a related artifact, and demonstrates their collective value to IT service management (ITSM).

Runbooks

Runbooks are collections of detailed instructions designed for IT operators to carry out specific tasks, often in response to incidents or routine operations (Microsoft, 2023). They typically include technical workflows, command sequences, escalation steps, and troubleshooting guidance. Runbooks are operational, ensuring that repetitive tasks are executed consistently, minimizing errors, and enabling faster recovery during incidents.

In an MSP context, runbooks support efficiency by reducing reliance on tribal knowledge. For instance, a runbook for restarting a failed database cluster ensures that Tier 1 engineers can resolve issues without escalating to senior staff. This accelerates incident resolution, supports Service Level Agreement (SLA) compliance, and increases customer satisfaction.

Policies

Policies are high-level statements of intent that establish principles, rules, and governance expectations within an organization (ISACA, 2020). Unlike runbooks, which are tactical, policies are strategic. They define what must be achieved and set boundaries for acceptable behavior.

For example, an IT security policy may mandate that all customer data must be encrypted in transit and at rest. This does not specify the technical steps but provides the overarching framework within which procedures and runbooks operate. Policies align IT service delivery with regulatory requirements, corporate governance, and industry standards such as ISO 27001.

Procedures (SOPs)

Procedures, also known as Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), provide detailed, step-by-step instructions on how to implement policies and support operational activities (Disterer, 2013; FDA, 2020). They standardize recurring activities, ensure repeatability, and provide accountability across teams.

For instance, a patch management procedure may specify the workflow for requesting, testing, approving, and deploying system updates. Similarly, a change management SOP might document the steps for submitting, reviewing, and implementing infrastructure changes. These documents are less technical than runbooks and more compliance-focused, ensuring processes are executed consistently across roles and teams.

By combining procedures and SOPs into one category, MSPs can streamline documentation and reduce redundancy while ensuring clarity between governance (policies), execution frameworks (procedures/SOPs), and technical task guides (runbooks).

Guidelines

Guidelines are flexible recommendations intended to influence behavior without being mandatory. Unlike policies, which are binding, or procedures, which prescribe exact steps, guidelines provide best-practice advice to improve efficiency, quality, or consistency (FDA, 2020).

For example, an MSP might issue a guideline for naming conventions in cloud infrastructure or preferred escalation paths during a system outage. While not strictly enforced, these recommendations promote standardization and reduce operational friction. Guidelines are particularly valuable in dynamic environments where strict procedures may not cover every scenario, but where consistency and alignment remain desirable.

Comparative Analysis

While runbooks, policies, procedures/SOPs, and guidelines differ in scope and purpose, they share similarities in promoting consistency, compliance, and efficiency. The key differences lie in their abstraction levels:

• Policies: Strategic, high-level, outcome-focused.

• Procedures/SOPs: Tactical, role-based, and compliance-driven.

• Runbooks: Operational, technical, and task-specific.

• Guidelines: Advisory, flexible, and best-practice oriented.

For MSPs, aligning these documents ensures a seamless flow from governance to execution. For example, a security policy may require multi-factor authentication, a procedure/SOP may define enrollment steps for users, a runbook may provide technical steps for resetting a locked MFA token, and a guideline may recommend user training practices to reduce lockouts.

Contribution to Outcomes

Each document type contributes uniquely to service outcomes in MSP and ITSM environments, ensuring that governance, compliance, and operational efficiency are balanced effectively.

Policies play a foundational role by safeguarding compliance, reducing regulatory risk, and aligning IT practices with the overarching business strategy. They establish the guiding principles and non-negotiable expectations that frame all subsequent documentation. For example, a data retention policy ensures the organization adheres to legal requirements for record-keeping and regulatory frameworks such as GDPR or HIPAA. By clearly defining boundaries and governance principles, policies help MSPs avoid costly penalties and maintain customer trust.

Procedures and SOPs ensure consistent execution and accountability across teams by translating high-level policy requirements into repeatable workflows. Unlike abstract policies, procedures provide operational clarity by outlining the exact steps for processes such as change management, incident handling, or patch deployment. This reduces variability in execution, making outcomes predictable and auditable. For MSPs, well-defined procedures also enhance transparency, providing clients with confidence that services are delivered in a controlled and reliable manner.

Runbooks enhance operational efficiency, minimize downtime, and improve incident response by providing frontline staff with technical playbooks for action. These documents often include automated scripts, diagnostic steps, and escalation procedures, allowing even junior staff to perform complex recovery tasks without deep expertise. In high-pressure situations such as a major outage, runbooks significantly reduce mean time to resolution (MTTR) by providing clear, actionable steps. This not only preserves SLA commitments but also strengthens client confidence in the MSP’s ability to deliver resilient services.

Guidelines serve a different but equally important function by promoting alignment and standardization without imposing rigid requirements. They provide best-practice recommendations that influence behavior while leaving room for flexibility and adaptation. For instance, a guideline on preferred logging practices may encourage consistency across teams but still allow deviations when justified by unique circumstances. In fast-changing environments, where rigid rules can sometimes stifle innovation or adaptability, guidelines strike a balance by fostering uniformity without reducing agility.

Taken together, these document types ensure that MSPs are not only compliant with governance requirements but also capable of delivering consistent, high-quality, and customer-centric services. Their interplay enables an organization to achieve efficiency in day-to-day operations while maintaining long-term strategic alignment with business objectives.

Conclusion

In MSP environments, confusion between runbooks, procedures, policies, and guidelines can hinder efficiency and compliance. Recognizing their differences and interdependencies is crucial for building a mature ITSM framework. Policies set direction, procedures/SOPs establish repeatable workflows, runbooks operationalize technical tasks, and guidelines provide flexible recommendations. Together, they create a comprehensive documentation ecosystem that enables MSPs to deliver consistent, compliant, and customer-focused services.

References

• Disterer, G. (2013). ISO/IEC 27000, 27001 and 27002 for information security management. Journal of Information Security, 4(2), 92–100. https://doi.org/10.4236/jis.2013.42011

• Food and Drug Administration (FDA). (2020). Guidance for industry: Standard operating procedures and documentation practices. U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. https://www.fda.gov/

• ISACA. (2020). COBIT 2019 framework: Governance and management objectives. ISACA.

• Microsoft. (2023). What is a runbook? Microsoft Learn. https://learn.microsoft.com/